NewsClick

NewsClick
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Covid-19
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • International
  • Sports
  • Articles
  • Videos
search
menu

INTERACTIVE ELECTION MAPS

image/svg+xml
  • All Articles
  • Newsclick Articles
  • All Videos
  • Newsclick Videos
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • Sports
  • International
  • Africa
  • Latin America
  • Palestine
  • Nepal
  • Pakistan
  • Sri Lanka
  • US
  • West Asia
About us
Subscribe
Follow us Facebook - Newsclick Twitter - Newsclick RSS - Newsclick
close menu
×
For latest updates on nCOVID-19 around the world visit our INTERACTIVE COVID MAP
Politics
India
Pakistan

Tariq Ali’s Golden Butterfly: A Hidden Lament for Today’s India

Ali explores the rise of religious fanaticism, dictatorship, majoritarianism and the military-mullah-feudal nexus in his native country, Pakistan.
Basharat Shameem
30 Apr 2020
Tariq Ali’s Golden Butterfly: A Hidden Lament for Today’s India

As totalitarianism intrudes into our lives in India, with journalists, activists, authors, poets and students being treated like criminals, recall George Orwell’s prophetic words: “Poetry might survive in a totalitarian age, and certain arts or half-arts, such as architecture, might even find tyranny beneficial, but the prose writer would have no choice between silence or death.” Recall also the eminent Marxist intellectual and author Tariq Ali’s novel, which depicts a dystopic authoritarian regime in his 2010 novel, Night of the Golden Butterfly, also comes to mind. Ali explores the rise of religious fanaticism, dictatorship, majoritarianism and the military-mullah-feudal nexus in his native country, Pakistan.

Ali’s work alludes to a host of contemporary issues from western imperialism to racism and immigration, and even harks back to the modern history of China to draw parallels with—and between—the democratic regimes of today. Dictatorship and capitulation of the state to religious fundamentalism are the framework of this novel, which has immense allegorical significance for contemporary India’s current collapse into dystopia.

The main protagonist and narrator, Lahore-born Dara is a famous writer who now lives in London. A cosmopolitan left-wing critic from an affluent Pakistan family that has lived through Partition—rather like Ali in real life—he is named after Dara Shukoh, the 17th century ‘secular’ Mughal poet and prince. Shukoh, modern-day readers in India and Pakistan would immediately grasp, was imprisoned by his more radical brother, the sixth Mughal emperor Aurangzeb. If this does not drag readers into current events, a host of other analogies in the narrative do the job.

Dara, now middle-aged, is contacted by an old progressive friend from his student days in Pakistan Punjab, Mohammed Aflatun “Plato”. Plato is a painter; free-spirited, crazily intelligent, bawdy and anti-clerical. He wants Dara to write his biography. The enterprise reunites them and their old circle of progressive friends who once belonged to the radical intellectual milieu of 1960s Pakistan.

In Lahore the four college students, Dara, Zahid, Plato and Hanif (“Confucius”) had begun their political and intellectual comradeship based on mutual Marxist yearnings. Dara sets up a multi-vocal narrative in which, more than 40 years later, the events associated with their lives are interwoven in the biography he is writing.

The plot combines friendship, betrayal and reconciliation. One reunion is with his former love interest, Jindié, a Chinese-origin Pakistani woman and her husband Zahid. Zahid was Dara’s former best friend and a staunch Marxist, but he had betrayed his friends and their progressive ideas to support American imperialism and its conservative policies after becoming a famous doctor there.

This brings us to India in the present day, where ideological desertions are also taking place. Numerous erstwhile secular-liberals are shifting towards the right-wing camp. The deep sense of nostalgia for ‘good old cosmopolitan Pakistan’, now overwhelmed by religious fundamentalism and bigotry, pervades Ali’s novel. “Was it old friends I was mourning or an old city, an old world that had since changed so much and for the worse, a world in which expectations for a better future were always high…” The narrator’s recollections are a signal to present-day India of what the future may look like.

The novel can be interpreted as an elegiac lament on the once multicultural and free-thinking milieu of Lahore and other places in Pakistan, which have come under the grip of religious fanaticism. “I spoke of the country where I could not live, where people were spewed out and forced to seek refuge abroad, where human dignity had become wreckage. [A dissenting person’s] life was a living-death example of a human being putrefying in the filth that was our Fatherland...its rulers. Scum of the earth. Blind, uncaring monsters. Fatherland needs a tsunami to drown them and their ill-gotten gains,” Ali writes.

Compare this description with the poignant words written by Dalit activist and intellectual Anand Teltumbde, addressed to all Indians on 13 April, just prior to his arrest. “In the name of ‘nation’ such draconian legislations (as UAPA) that denude innocent people of their liberties and all constitutional rights are constitutionally validated. The jingoist nation and nationalism have got weaponized by the political class to destroy dissent and polarise people. The mass frenzy has accomplished complete de-rationalisation and inversion of meanings where destroyers of the nation become desh bhakts and selfless servers of people become desh drohis. As I see my India being ruined, it is with a feeble hope that I write to you at such a grim moment,” Teltumbde wrote.

The dark reality of the novel can is often a clear allegorical representation of contemporary India, where a tolerant social milieu and space for dissent are facing wreckage at the hands of a regime that has encouraged religious bigotry and brute majoritarianism. In India, too, the media and judicial institutions have capitulated to the ruling regime’s dictates. As Ali notes, indifferent rulers “preside over the kind of tyrannies that break a people’s heart and their pride”. The famous 1994 poem by Fahmida Riaz comes immediately to mind: “Tum bilkul hum jaise nikle. Tum bilkul hum jaise nikle.” (You, at last, turned out like us. So in the end you were just like us.)

The Night of the Golden Butterfly questions the authoritarian nationalisms backed by political consciousness, be it Sunni-Punjabi in Pakistan, Han in China or the White in the West. The author interrogates how a national identity is constructed, through a dynamic that is on the one hand homogenising and on the other fosters differences. The idea of a nation or community is built as homogenous, or unified and single-minded, to set it apart from other nations and communities. Ali strikes at this very core of this dynamic, shows up the idea of a nation as a misleading construct.

Both contemporary Pakistan and the story of 19th century China are alluded to in the novel. After the 1872 uprising of Muslims and their supporters in Yunnan against the Manchu/Han rulers, the emperor orders a genocide to wipe out the Sultanate of Suleyman in the province. The main motive is not religious, but political and economic, including fears that the Sultanate is gaining autonomy and respect beyond its domain. There is a corollary with another complex reality of Pakistan in this—the domination of the Punjabis, who make up its largest ethnolinguistic group—over all others. In the novel, Jindie slyly remarks in a letter she sends to Dara, “The talk of Han domination would have been brushed aside by all of you with contempt as it still is by Zahid. Perhaps the reason for this is that the Punjabis have become the Han equivalents of Fatherland, crushing other nationalities at will, but that’s your story. Better write it before the Baluch and the Pashtun and the Sindhi produce their own.”

The resemblance with today’s India, where the rise of Hindutva majoritarianism has thrust a singular agenda of hegemonic Hindi-Hindu-Hindustan over its diverse cultural, religious and linguistic denominations, cannot be missed.

Much of Ali’s novel, a work of fiction by definition, is already lived reality in contemporary India. Especially after 2014, democracy and republicanism have experienced a sudden epistemological break. This break is getting more penetrative and intense as time passes, posing grave existential questions about the survival of the foundations of the republic. Lynching, blood-thirst and venomous discourse about minorities and dissidents are routine today. Brute majoritarianism patronised by the rulers is penetrating all institutions—even communalising and weaponising the ongoing pandemic to repress an already-battered community.

But the malaise goes deeper. The eminent rights activist Gautam Navlakha wrote just before his recent arrest that a person is no longer innocent until proven guilty, while the reverse is quite true. In this Kafkaesque domain, the process itself becomes the punishment, quite in consonance with Orwellian dystopias. Those who speak against hate and violence are imprisoned while the perpetrators of criminal acts are licensed to roam free.

The author is a blogger and writer based in J&K. The views are personal.

Get the latest reports & analysis with people's perspective on Protests, movements & deep analytical videos, discussions of the current affairs in your Telegram app. Subscribe to NewsClick's Telegram channel & get Real-Time updates on stories, as they get published on our website.
Ethnicity in India
Pakistan India
Indian Partition
Tariq Ali
Anand Teltumbde
Gautam Navlakha
Fahmida Riaz
Religious Fanatics
majoritarianism
dictatorship
Related Stories
pD

Under the Cover of the Pandemic, States Cracked Down Even Harder

Maharashtra Govt Orders Probe Into 'Denial' of Specs to Navlakha in Taloja Jail

Maharashtra Govt Orders Probe Into 'Denial' of Specs to Navlakha in Taloja Jail

Humanity Most Important, Says HC on Gautam Navlakha’s 'Stolen' Specs

Humanity Most Important, Says HC on Gautam Navlakha’s 'Stolen' Specs

The Last Straw: Civil Society Must Step in When Law is no Longer About Justice

The Last Straw: Civil Society Must Step in When Law is no Longer About Justice

What the World Knows and Believes About India and Modi

What the World Knows and Believes About India and Modi

Stany Swamy

Stan Swamy’s Crime Is His Solidarity with the Marginalised

Sudha bharadwaj

SC Dismisses Sudha Bharadwaj’s Interim Bail Plea on Medical Grounds as Withdrawn

Juridical Viralities, Courts

Juridical Viralities, Courts and the Question of Justice

mahesh raut anand teltumbde

Bhima Koregaon: HC Seeks Explanation After Raut, Teltumbde Medical Reports Show Identical Details

rss politics

When Ascetics Stride Into Politics

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share

Related Stories

Ajay Gudavarthy

India Needs a New Anti-Majoritarian Self

16 January 2021
We learn from the majoritarian culture that is spreading around the world that its influence cannot be explaine
Ajay Gudavarthy

AIMIM and India’s Majoritarian Impasse

11 January 2021
The strategy of fielding candidates in local and state e
Nihalsing B Rathod

Lawyers Withstood Pressures and Defended Activists in the Bhima Koregaon Case

03 January 2021
As we leave behind 2020, with a new hope to resume our life, we leave behind not just memories, but many blistering wounds.

Pagination

  • Next page ››

More

  • CPIM COngress West Bengal

    Left, Congress Begin Seat Sharing Talks in West Bengal

  • Dangerous in WhatsApp's Privacy Update

    What's New, Not-So-New and Dangerous in WhatsApp's Privacy Update?

  • Arnab Goswami and Partha Dasgupta.

    Did Arnab Goswami Have Prior Knowledge of Balakot Air Strike?

  • Munawar Faruqi.

    Munawar Faruqui Case Makes Idea of Democracy Illusory

  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with
about