NewsClick

NewsClick
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • International
  • Sports
  • Podcasts
  • Articles
  • Videos
search
menu
  • All Podcasts
  • All Articles
  • Newsclick Articles
  • All Videos
  • Newsclick Videos
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • Sports
  • International
  • Africa
  • Latin America
  • Palestine
  • Nepal
  • Pakistan
  • Sri Lanka
  • US
  • West Asia
About us
Contact us
Subscribe
Follow us Facebook - Newsclick Twitter - Newsclick RSS - Newsclick
close menu
Politics
India

A Plea with a Broken Wing

Recent rulings—especially Rafale—can make true-blue regime supporters smile.
Hiren Gohain
19 Nov 2019
Recent rulings—especially Rafale—can

Separation of powers is a hallmark of all genuine democracies. In the same way, it is a priority for dictatorial or fascist governments to emasculate courts and bring them under the influence of the executive authority. Likewise, a desperate struggle to preserve the essence of democracy often shows up in courts’ resistance to unlawful expansion of executive power. It would seem that right now we are watching the throes of such a struggle in our own country, though with waning hope.

The Chief Justice of India, who demitted office on 16 November, had left a batch of cases of utmost gravity and consequence to be considered during the week before he retires. The nation was aware of their critical importance for the state and the Constitution. It waited with bated breath for the outcome. The results in all these cases have disappointed all but diehard supporters of the government.

The honourable judges missed their chance to stave off an imminent threat to the Constitution. It has failed to call to order a rampaging executive that has thousands of cheerleaders out on the streets.

These cases, mostly arising out of Public Interest Litigations (PILs) filed by people anxious about the burgeoning crisis of democracy, seem to have been decided in a manner heedless of the grave perils ahead. The Ayodhya verdict has gone into meticulous detail, but apparently with a view to avoiding a certain compelling conclusion rather than ensuring logic cast in iron. Sabarimala seems to have granted greater weight to argument from faith than to implications of the Constitution.

Above all, the Rafale case has been dismissed in a summary fashion, brushing aside some really challenging reasons for the desired review of the 2018 verdict. The most disturbing feature of the judgment is its peremptory tone, which practically amounts to severe strictures against the petitioners, Yashwant Sinha, Arun Shourie and Prashant Bhushan. They have been charged with turning themselves into an “appellate authority” to determine each aspect of the contract and “call upon the court to do the same”. To my eyes, the petition appears no more than an expression of distress at a strong whiff of corruption involving huge wastage of public—tax payers’—money.

It is common knowledge that the biggest scams everywhere take place in the defence sector, and the plea of national security should not be allowed to draw a veil upon them. The petitioners are therefore discharging a public duty worthy of honour. Instead, they have been brusquely pulled up.

The affidavit submitted by the government in 2018 not only contains most arrant falsehoods but also distortions of facts that might be construed as attempts to mislead the highest court. This itself should call for some serious rebuke. There was none. Further, the tone of the judgment is such as to discourage any searching question on the government’s conduct or misconduct.

It behoves people in positions of highest authority, who wield enormous power, to maintain the dignity of such positions with dignified sober language and patience. In order that justice is not only done but also seen to be done, a judgment ought to be worded so that it removes all doubts and misgivings.

The three petitioners had only desired an enquiry by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), which had been stalled only because of the overnight intervention by the government, in view of certain indisputable circumstances. They did not directly accuse the government of corruption.

Further, the Supreme Court’s decisions in the Ayodhya dispute and the petition seeking a review of its Sabarimala ruling to a larger bench have privileged faith above the Constitution. In both cases, in different ways, solid constitutional principles are being overshadowed by those of faith.

It is no secret that some quarters would be happy to replace the present Constitution. In this situation, one hopes and prays that the highest court treads warily—but firmly.

The author writes on socio-political issues and is a literary critic. The views are personal.

Central Bureau of Investigation
supreme court
CJI Ranjan Gogoi
Narendra Modi
Yashwant sinha
Arun Shourie
Prashant Bhushan
Dassault Rafale
Rajnath Singh
Nirmala Sitharaman
Related Stories
Delhi Anaj Mandi Fire: 43 Dead

Delhi Anaj Mandi Fire: 43 Dead, Chilling Accounts of Dying Workers Emerge

DUTA March to Parliament Barricaded

DUTA March to Parliament Barricaded; Teachers Court Arrest

Supreme Court

Local Body Polls: SC to Hear DMK Plea Against Reservation Policy on Wednesday

More than 950 scientists

More Than 950 Scientists Call for the Immediate Withdrawal of CAB

Jharkhand Elections, workers

Jharkhand: Do Workers Not Have the Right to Live?

Defence

Make in India a Failure in Defence Sector ?

प्याज़ रुलाए

Soaring Onion Prices and 'Acche Din'

Why Unsigned Addenda to Ayodhya Verdict Must Go

Why Unsigned Addenda to Ayodhya Verdict Must Go

What is the Real Intention Behind

What is the Real Intention Behind CAB and the Future Pan-Indian NRC?

Telecom

Is Rise in Telecom Tariffs Result of Price Fixing?


Related Stories

Garment Factory
Newsclick Team

Economic Slump: Banian City Workers in Distress

11 December 2019
The city of Tirupur in Tamil Nadu is known as 'Banian City' or as the 'knitwear capital of India'.
The Declining Economy
Peeyush Sharma

The Declining Economy of the ‘Holy Cow’

11 December 2019
The cattle economy has suffered considerably in recent years, threatening livelihoods of India’s poorest.
onion bihar
Ujjawal Krishnam

How Onion Retailers in Bihar’s Bettiah Town Are Braving Price Spike

10 December 2019
Bettiah (Bihar): “Who told you that we are profiteering?” says Md.

Pagination

  • Next page ››

More

  • Kashmir

    Abrogation of Art 370: How Valley Students Are Suffering

  • Karnataka: Marching Anganwadi

    Karnataka: Marching Anganwadi Workers Receive Written Assurance, Defer Protest

  • CAB in Rajya Sabha on 11th December

    Citizenship Bill: Tamils, Madheshis and Rohingyas Are Also Persecuted Minorities

  • Karvy Scandal Sends Shockwaves Across

    Karvy Scandal Sends Shockwaves Across Domestic Brokerage Industry

  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with
about
contact