NewsClick

NewsClick
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • International
  • Sports
  • Podcasts
  • Articles
  • Videos
search
menu
  • All Podcasts
  • All Articles
  • Newsclick Articles
  • All Videos
  • Newsclick Videos
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • Sports
  • International
  • Africa
  • Latin America
  • Palestine
  • Nepal
  • Pakistan
  • Sri Lanka
  • US
  • West Asia
About us
Contact us
Subscribe
Follow us Facebook - Newsclick Twitter - Newsclick RSS - Newsclick
close menu
Politics
International

In a 10-1 Vote, Supreme Court Stays Brazil’s Lula Transfer to São Paulo

Decision to transfer ex-president was about “shifting focus,” a jurist told Brasil de Fato: “Lula should be released”
Brasil de Fato
08 Aug 2019
Supreme Court Stays Brazil

Brazil’s Supreme Court stayed on Wednesday the transfer of former president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva from Curitiba to São Paulo just hours after a judge ruled in favor of a petition filed by the Federal Police. The vote was 10 to 1.

The country’s top court ruling came after Lula’s defense lawyers filed a motion for a preliminary injunction to release him following this morning’s court decision, which his supporters considered “a move to draw attention away from important matters.”

The motion was filed regarding a habeas corpus petition that is pending since last year in the Guarujá beachside apartment case, which is expected to be reviewed by justice Gilmar Mendes.

His lawyers questioned the court’s decision to transfer the ex-president “in a moment when new and serious information has been revealed regarding the conduct of agents involved in Operation Car Wash,” after The Intercept Brasil, in partnership with other Brazilian outlets, started a series of exposés on the case.

His lawyers also argued that, in case the Supreme Court didn’t rule to release the leftist leader, he should not be transferred to São Paulo.

The 11 top court justices delivered their vote after 72 members of parliament of 12 parties met with the Supreme Court chief justice, Dias Toffoli, calling the justices to stand up to the latest court decision. The meeting was called by the House Speaker, Rodrigo Maia.

Earlier today, a court ruled in favor of a petition filed by the Federal Police Bureau in Curitiba to transfer Lula to a prison in the city of Tremembé, São Paulo, sparking a backlash among the popular leader’s supporters and attorneys.

“Lula should be released”

After the court decision early on Wednesday to transfer Lula, Fernando Hideo, a criminal lawyer and member of the Brazilian Association of Jurists for Democracy (ABJD), spoke with Brasil de Fato and argued that the Workers’ Party leader’s defense should not shift focus from their goal, which is Lula’s freedom.

“The focus is that Lula should be released. It’s not about the quality of the place where he is jailed. Lula should not be in prison, period. Having Lula serve a prison sentence is a moral abomination,” Hideo said, adding that he has no doubt that the decision by a Curitiba-based judge to transfer the popular leader to São Paulo was out of the ordinary.

“It’s unusual, because it was a decision regarding a petition filed by the Federal Police, which is headed by Sérgio Moro, the Justice minister,” the criminal law expert said.

Moro, who presided over the Car Wash corruption scandal, is being exposed by a series of investigative pieces that show his bias against the ex-president.

Hideo argued that the link between Moro and the possible transfer of Lula should not be brushed aside, as it is part of the “media chess board.”

“Just when the exposés on Operation Car Wash started to reach their pinnacle, president [Jair] Bolsonaro comes along making infamous comments, appointing his son [as ambassador to the US], and starting to create a mess to shift focus,” the jurist pointed out.

Hideo also underscored that the Federal Police’s arguments to ask for Lula’s transfer from Curitiba are not legal, “but they are always political.” “They mention disturbance and protests, so the political nature of the request is blatant.”

Edition: João Paulo Soares | English version by Aline Scátola

Courtesy: Peoples Dispatch
Curitiba
Free Lula
Jair Bolsonaro
Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva
Lula Livre
Operation Car Wash
Sergio Moro
Related Stories
Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva Released from Jail

Lula to Supporters: “We Cannot Allow Militiamen to Destroy the Country We Have Built”

Lula

Lula Released from Prison, Developments in Syria, Privacy and Intelligence after Pegasus

Lula released

Lula’s First Speech After Release: Gratitude to Supporters and Plans to Tour Brazil

Latest Developments in the Marielle

Latest Developments in the Marielle Franco Case and how Bolsonaro Could be Involved

Jair Bolsonaro

Latest Developments in the Marielle Franco Case and How Bolsonaro Could be Involved

Lula

Lula: “You Have No Idea How Much Drive I Have to Fight”

In prison since April 2018 after a politically-charged trial, the Brazilian ex-president granted an exclusive interview to Brasil de Fato / José Eduardo Bernardes/Brasil de Fato

Exclusive | Lula: “Supreme Court Will Decide Whether to Follow the Constitution”

I Will Not Trade My Dignity for My Freedom, Says Lula

Thousands to the Streets of Brazil

Cry of the Excluded Brings tens of Thousands to the Streets of Brazil

Amazon Fires and Crony Capitalism

Amazon Fires, Bolsonaro’s White Nationalism and Crony Capitalism


Related Stories

Brasil de Fato

Lula Returns to North East of Brazil for Free Lula Festival

18 November 2019
On Sunday November 17, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva returned to his beloved home state of Pernambuco to participate in the Free Lula festival in the c
Guaidó backers forcibly enter Venezuelan embassy in Brasília
Brasil de Fato

Guaidó Backers Forcibly Enter Venezuelan Embassy in Brasília

15 November 2019
Tensions remained high throughout Wednesday after a group of trespassers wearing clothes in support of the self-proclaimed president of Venezuela J
Peoples BRICS
Brasil de Fato

Peoples’ BRICS Summit Closing Statement: “We Demand Changes So We can have a Future”

14 November 2019
The closing statement of the P

Pagination

  • Next page ››

More

  • Roadside Vendors to Meat Sellers, Soaring Onion Prices Hit Business in Bihar

    Roadside Vendors to Meat Sellers, Soaring Onion Prices Hit Business in Bihar

  • Ajit Pawar's Clean Chit Creates Huge Embarrassment For BJP

  • Emergence of Language as a Product of Social Interactions

    Emergence of Language as a Product of Social Interactions

  • Kamal Nath

    MP Govt Under Debt, But Paid Rs 36 Crore to Dismantled NGO

  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with
about
contact