Climate Change: Tourist Destinations Under Threat
A victim of climate change? The longest natural beach on Mallorca, Playa Es Trenc, is steadily becoming narrower
If you want to see firsthand the impact of climate change, take a trip to Es Trenc, one of Mallorca's finest beaches. Here, massive concrete bunkers — once built by Spain's then-Dictator Francisco Franco — were originally hidden amid the sand dunes. Today, these structures stand out like sore thumbs — rising sea-water levels have swallowed up parts of the beach and radically altered this coastal landscape. In total, scientists have found that Es Trenc beach is now 40 meters shorter than it once was. If global warming continues as is projected, many more Mallorca beaches will disappear into the sea.
This bunker was once hidden among the dunes.
Record visitor numbers, vanishing beaches
"We are seeing large-scale land loss in the Mediterranean region," says Thomas Dworak, who coordinated a Federal Environment Agency study on the effects of global warming on tourism. This is a very concerning prospect for islands like Mallorca, which are popular with holidaymakers precisely because of their expansive beaches. For now, though, none of this is reflected in visitor numbers. On the contrary. Mallorca is seeing a record number of guests this summer.
"There is little evidence to suggest that people are changing their travel behavior because of climate change," says Dworak. Even though warnings about the consequences for the tourism industry have been mounting for many years, he says there have only been a few studies that demonstrate concrete effects.
Eleven people died when part of a glacier broke off in the Italian Dolomites in July.
"Many Europeans are creatures of habit," says Dworak. "Someone who spent the past 20 years going on holiday in Italy will keep doing just that." Even shocking natural disasters, like the glacier collapse in Italy's Dolomites in early July, which killed 11 people, do not seem to leave a lasting impressing strong enough to change people's minds.
Limited impact, so far
"If the very same locations suffer repeated flooding, or glacier collapses, it will eventually impact tourism in that region," says Dagmar Lund-Durlacher, a professor of sustainable tourism management at Modul University Vienna. But so far, she adds, such events have occurred sporadically in different areas. "People are aware of the danger but they don't associate it with a specific region." The Caribbean, she says, is an exception. In September 2019, tropical storm Dorian hit the Bahamas, causing massive destruction which brought the tourist sector to its knees.
Hurricane Dorian caused wide-spread destruction in the Bahamas
Ski resorts, meanwhile, are among the regions hardest-hit by global warming, as rising temperatures reduce the amount of snowfall. "This is where the connection between climate change and tourism is most apparent," says Dworak. "If a ski resort received little or no snow for several consecutive years, winters sports enthusiasts will stay away."
Ski resorts use snow cannons to make up for lack of snowfall
Alpine regions know this problem all too well, though many have resorted to snow cannons to make up for missing snowfall. Artificial snow production, says South Tyrol Tourism Minister Arnold Schuler, has served the North Italian region well. Tourists keep coming in the winter months to go skiing and snowboarding. So far, visitor numbers in winter and summer have remained stable. Still, Schuler admits that artificial snow production only works at certain, low temperatures. There are already areas in South Tyrol where skiing is no longer possible all year round because of shrinking glaciers and rising temperatures.
Time to adapt
Vanishing beaches, a higher frequency of storms and floods as well as lack of snowfall are only some consequences of global warming that are bound to have an impact on the tourist industry. Droughts and heat waves will also put tourists off visiting affected regions, as experts have warned for years. Back in 2008, the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) already highlighted how vulnerable the tourist industry is to climate change. Forest fires, new infectious diseases, biodiversity loss, jellyfish plagues due to warming oceans — these are just some aspects of global warming that could present major problems for popular tourist destinations in the future. Cooler regions in the north are thus likely to receive more tourists.
Portugal and Spain have been hit by a major heat-wave.
"There may already be some tourists who avoid the Mediterranean during summer because of the heat," says sustainable tourism expert Lund-Durlacher. She says while only a limited number of tourists are so far staying clear of southern Europe, popular holiday destinations should start thinking about adapting to changing climate. "Sooner or later," she says "they must act, or tourists will eventually stay away."
There is no single blueprint for adapting to global warming. Each holiday destination needs to take region-specific measures, says Dworak. While certain African national parks are threatened by forest fires, parts of Greece face acute water shortages. Sylt, Germany's popular North Sea island, is seeing its beaches eroding. All this means solutions must be tailored to the respective region affected. For some locals, it may mean looking for employment outside the tourist industry. In Italy, Dworak says, this may simply mean encouraging tourists to visit in spring and autumn, instead of the sweltering summer months.
Will Mallorca beach holidays become a thing of the past?
Rising sea level present a growing problem for the island of Mallorca, yet nobody knows how to stop vast quantities of sand being washed into the sea. These days, there is only space for three instead of six huts along Es Trenc beach. And the number of parasols and sun loungers has been cut down as well.
These seemingly marginal and banal changes, however, point to a much more troubling and far-reaching transformation taking place.
This article was originally written in German
Get the latest reports & analysis with people's perspective on Protests, movements & deep analytical videos, discussions of the current affairs in your Telegram app. Subscribe to NewsClick's Telegram channel & get Real-Time updates on stories, as they get published on our website.