NewsClick

NewsClick
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Covid-19
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • International
  • Sports
  • Articles
  • Videos
search
menu

SUBSCRIBE AND SUPPORT

image/svg+xml
  • All Articles
  • Newsclick Articles
  • All Videos
  • Newsclick Videos
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • Sports
  • International
  • Africa
  • Latin America
  • Palestine
  • Nepal
  • Pakistan
  • Sri Lanka
  • US
  • West Asia
About us
Grievance Redressal Mechanism
Newsletter
Facebook - Newsclick Twitter - Newsclick Instagram - Newsclick Youtube - Newsclick RSS - Newsclick
close menu
×
You deserve independent, critical media. Subscribe and Support
Covid-19
India
International

How the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy Proved Superior to Living With Covid

Significantly fewer deaths, reduced infections, a lower likelihood of new virus variants and far better economic outcomes are the visible benefits of the dynamic zero-Covid strategy.
C. Saratchand
02 May 2022
Covid 19 UP warriors-min

Two years have passed since Covid-19 was first detected, and two approaches to try and deal with the disease, namely “living with Covid” and the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy, have emerged. Experience so far conclusively demonstrates that in terms of public health and economic metrics, the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy is superior to living with Covid. This evaluation is best exemplified by the USA, where living with Covid has led to almost a million deaths. It is the single largest cause of death in US history, apart from the genocide of native Americans and African American slavery. 

The United States could have avoided most of these deaths if its policymakers had been willing to adopt the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy. However, that did not happen since it would have involved a reckoning with “un-American” initiatives such as universal healthcare, besides having to advance other welfare provisions for working people, such as universal paid sick leave.

However, the “dynamic” element in the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy refers not only to aiming for zero Covid-19 infections over time but continuous adaptive evolution of the strategy itself in light of developments.

In the initial stage, when there were no vaccines for Covid-19, the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy involved non-pharmaceutical interventions such as lockdowns, travel restrictions, and universal testing, besides institutional quarantine and medical treatment of the infected. However, once vaccines were developed, mass vaccination became an additional policy instrument in the toolkit of the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy. 

Countries that adopted this strategy, such as China, handled the pandemic better than the living with Covid approach on all public health and economic activity metrics. They have significantly fewer deaths, a reduced number of infections, a lower likelihood of the emergence of new virus variants (since lower transmission results in fewer mutations and recombinations of the virus that causes Covid-19) and far better economic outcomes. Free treatment of the infected has played a crucial role in the effectiveness of the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy.

Vaccines do not confer permanent immunity against existing vaccines. Nor do they necessarily offer assured protection against newer variants of the virus. But they do significantly reduce the likelihood of death and severe disease due to Covid-19 caused by existing or newer variants. Further, no matter how effective non-pharmaceutical interventions, treatment practices and vaccines are, there will likely be some outbreaks of Covid-19. Therefore, the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy has to evolve to deal with these challenges. This evolution could include several elements besides those which are already in place.

First, policymakers who advocate the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy must emphasise masking in public places in their country till Covid-19 is globally eradicated. This will ensure that even if the virus re-enters the community (due to false negatives in some tests, for instance) where the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy is in place, its further transmission will be limited. Such an outbreak will be more easily contained and overcome. Emphasis on masking is also possible in countries that are living with Covid. However, policymakers in these countries, especially the United States, project non-masking as a sign of having recovered “freedom”. In other countries living with Covid, the policy emphasis on masking waxes and wanes with the number of reported infections. This happens because of the attenuation of past gains in public health and scientific temper due to the hegemony of the neo-liberal project.

Second, regular random testing in communities will help in the early discovery of undetected outbreaks. This will allow Covid-19 mitigation measures to be implemented at an early stage of an outbreak. Thereby, possible outbreaks can be rapidly contained and eliminated. This is possible in countries living with Covid, but neo-liberal “fiscal constraints” tend to militate against such initiatives.

Third, an increase in genomic sequencing of positive cases will help in early identification of new variants of the virus (including “imported” variants). As a result, scientific work to appropriately tweak existing vaccines—and their future employment in booster doses and vaccination of the unvaccinated—adapting current treatment protocols etc., can be expedited. The ability of countries living with Covid to adopt such a policy intervention tends to, once again, run up against neo-liberal requirements of “sound finance”.

Four, though there is no long-run trade-off between public health and economic activity under the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy, there is such a trade-off in the short run if lockdowns are required. To deal with this short-run trade-off, the country in question could maintain stocks and inventories of goods to minimise short-term disruptions in value chains. Holding inventories will be rational only if the cost of doing so is lower than the cost of mitigation of lockdown-induced disruptions to value chains. We may safely assume that holding such inventories would be rational in most cases.

Five, if granular regulation of interactions between the uninfected and possibly infected people is possible through a participative technology-driven process (informed by solidarity), then lockdowns can be appropriately blended with the calibrated reopening of economic activities.

Six, mass testing and institutional quarantine and treatment of the infected could allow for phased, geographically-sequenced, reopening of economic activities within areas where the Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy is tackling an outbreak.

Finally, countries that adopt a Dynamic Zero Covid Strategy need to advocate more actively for countries living with Covid to adopt this strategy. It will require countries living with Covid to break with the neo-liberal project. Success in this advocacy would not only rapidly overcome the pandemic but could also advance international cooperation on a wider range of issues of global importance.

The author is a professor at the Department of Economics, Satyawati College, University of Delhi. The views are personal

Get the latest reports & analysis with people's perspective on Protests, movements & deep analytical videos, discussions of the current affairs in your Telegram app. Subscribe to NewsClick's Telegram channel & get Real-Time updates on stories, as they get published on our website.
US Covid Deaths
living with covid
dynamic zero covid strategy
Covid Vaccine
COVID Deaths
Neo-liberal
COVID-19
Universal Healthcare
Lockdown
Related Stories
Chennai, June 03 (ANI): Health workers inspect passengers arriving from high risk countries for MonkeyPox symptoms, at Chennai International Airport, on Friday.

Will Monkeypox Outbreak Replay AIDS and Covid-19 Script?

COVID cases in India

Active COVID-19 Cases in Country Cross One-Lakh Mark After 122 Days

Call for Action Against COVID-19 ‘Criminals’ Blocking Vaccine Patent Waiver

South Korea Approves First Homemade COVID-19 Vaccine

RBI Officers’ Association Seeks Review of Unified

RBI Paper Misinterpreting Reality, Kerala’s Public Spending Actually Fuelling Development, Say Experts

WTO Ministerial Conference

Death Trumps Life at Geneva Ministerial

Supreme Court draws a parallel between 2002 Gujarat pogrom and the COVID second wave to rule out criminal conspiracy

Supreme Court Draws a Parallel Between 2002 Gujarat Pogrom and the COVID Second Wave to Rule Out Criminal Conspiracy

Covid 19 testing MP.

COVID-19: India Adds 12,781 New Cases, Positivity Rate Over 4% After 130 Days

Asha Workers

ASHA Workers Gather in Lucknow, Demand Minimum Wage and Employee Benefits

Lviv, Mar 06 (ANI): A view of a covered statue amid the Russia-Ukraine crisis at Rynok Square, in Lviv on Sunday.

A Possible Political-Diplomatic Solution to the Ukraine Conflict

Resentment Brews After Pharma Major Pfizer Terminates 200 ‘Field Force’ Staff in India

Resentment Brews After Pharma Major Pfizer Terminates 200 ‘Field Force’ Staff in India

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share
You deserve independent, critical media. We want readers like you. Support independent, critical media. Subscribe to Newsclick.

Subscribe and Support


Latest

  • sfi

    WB: SFI Calls for Rallies Against NEP Throughout Eastern India

  • TN: Students Accuse Central University of Suppressing Dissenting Voices, Favouring Right-WIng Activism

    TN: Students Accuse Central University of Suppressing Dissent, Favouring Right-Wing Activism

  • nupur sharma

    Nupur Sharma Single-Handedly Responsible for What’s Happening in Country: SC

  • Gig

    India's Gig Economy to Expand to 2.35 Crore Workers by 2029-30: Niti Aayog

  • Load More
Newsletter
About us
Grievance Redressal Mechanism