NewsClick

NewsClick
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Covid-19
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • International
  • Sports
  • Articles
  • Videos
search
menu

INTERACTIVE ELECTION MAPS

image/svg+xml
  • All Articles
  • Newsclick Articles
  • All Videos
  • Newsclick Videos
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • Sports
  • International
  • Africa
  • Latin America
  • Palestine
  • Nepal
  • Pakistan
  • Sri Lanka
  • US
  • West Asia
About us
Subscribe
Follow us Facebook - Newsclick Twitter - Newsclick RSS - Newsclick
close menu
×
For latest updates on nCOVID-19 around the world visit our INTERACTIVE COVID MAP
Elections 2019
Politics
India

Modi Won Power, Not Battle of Ideas, Says Amartya Sen

The Hindu nationalist movement has won something in terms of power but nothing particularly serious in the battle of ideas, the Nobel laureate economist said, citing BJP’s embarrassment over Pragya Thakur’s praise for Gandhi’s killer
Sandip Chakraborty
25 May 2019
 Amartya Sen

Image Courtesy: Business Today

Kolkata: Drilling holes into the ‘impressive achievements’ of Prime Minister Narendra Modi in managing a landslide victory in the Lok Sabha elections, Nobel laureate Amartya Sen said ‘Modi has won power not battle of ideas.”

In an article in the New York Times, the noted economist, who has rubbed the Sangh Parivar the wrong way on several occasions, inviting their ire, noted that Modi had changed his own discourse since 2014 as he had “accomplished little” of what he had promised. This is why he could not “brag” about it in his great oratory during the election campaign, and focussed on nationalism, national security and fear of Pakistan.

“Just as the Falklands War in 1982 shored up support for Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher of Britain, who dramatically gained in popularity, the border battles with Pakistan in February helped Mr. Modi immensely in the elections”, he said.

The Nobel laureate pointed out that during Modi’s first term, “unemployment is very high, a 45-year peak, economic growth is faltering and uneven in its impact, elementary health care remains comprehensively neglected, and there has been no striking decrease of red tape and corruption”.

Admitting that there may be an element of truth that “India has changed”, he observed that political support for the BJP’s victory came disproportionately from the Hindus, though about 200 million Indian citizens are Muslims.

Sen’s criticism of the saffron brigade led by Modi comes close on the heels of an article in London- based newspaper, The Guardian, which in its editorial commented that Modi landslide victory was “bad for Indian soul”. It also said that the world did not need another national populist leader who pursued a pro-business agenda while “trading in fake news and treating minorities as 2nd class citizens.“

Sen described Modi as a “a fiery orator” who “has been able to influence others’ thinking with his striking readiness to make political use of hatred and loathing — for people with different ways of life (leftists, rationalists, liberal intellectuals) and for those with different origins and religious beliefs, such as Muslims. Former B.J.P. leaders, like the unaggressive Atal Bihari Vajpayee, would certainly be unable to compete”.

He said in Indian politics, many may prefer to conclude that BJP has won what is called “the ideological argument” against the Congress, but “there has been no particular victory for the philosophy of Hindu nationalism and no noticeable vanquishing of the idea of inclusiveness and unity championed by Gandhi, Nehru and Tagore.”

“The Hindu nationalist movement has won something in terms of power but nothing particularly serious in the battle of ideas. Pragya Thakur, a B.J.P. activist, said recently that Mohandas Gandhi’s assassin, Nathuram Godse, was a patriot. This embarrassed even the B.J.P., which made her formally apologize,” he wrote, adding that she would now enter Indian Parliament, which is a victory in terms of power, “but not in the battle of ideas”.

Sen regretted that the Opposition had not paid the required attention to the “battle of ideas”, and called for greater engagement in that area, while emphasising that the first thing was “not to confuse the two battles”.

Get the latest reports & analysis with people's perspective on Protests, movements & deep analytical videos, discussions of the current affairs in your Telegram app. Subscribe to NewsClick's Telegram channel & get Real-Time updates on stories, as they get published on our website.
Narendra Modi
2019 Lok Sabha elections
Amartya Sen
Pragya Thakur
BJP
Atal Bihari Vajpayee
Related Stories
Bengal Elections: No Question of Post-Poll Tie-up With Mamata: Adhir Chowhdury

Bengal Elections: No Question of Post-Poll Tie-up With Mamata: Adhir Chowdhury

abbas siddique

Bengal Elections: Mamata Trying to Divide People by Seeking Votes on Communal Lines, Says Abbas Siddiqi

Will Sangita Sengar talk about BJP’s beti bachao slogan when campaigning in UP?

Will Sangita Sengar Talk About BJP’s Beti Bachao Slogan When Campaigning in UP?

BJP modi

Why do BJP and Modi Dress Communal Politics in Secular Attire?

Asembly

Puducherry Elections: Desperate BJP Allegedly Bribes Voters, Makes Huge Promises

Arvind Kejriwal Oath

Question Mark Over Constitutionality of Amendment Giving More Power to Delhi LG

Singur

Bengal Elections: 13 Years After Tata's Ouster by TMC, Singur Seeks Industrialisation

local body poll

Himachal Civic Polls: Congress Gets Majority in Palampur, Solan; BJP in Mandi

Delhi riots

Delhi violence: Court grants stay in trial of case where complainant is also accused

srijan

Bengal Elections: In Singur, Sangjukta Morcha’s Srijan Touching Hearts with Humility and Promise of Industrialisation

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share

Related Stories

Asad Rizvi

Activists Condemn Candidature of Rape Convict Sengar’s Wife in Panchayat Elections

11 April 2021
Women's organisations have condemned the Bhartiya Janta Party’s decision to announce the candidature of the wife of rape convict Kuldeep
Ayaskant Das

How a Sand Mining Contractor Partially Diverted Yamuna's Flow at Haryana-Uttar Pradesh Border

11 April 2021
New Delhi: A mining contractor has been found to have partially diverted the flow of the Yamuna river at the Ha
Newsclick Team

Farmers Shutdown KMP Highway, Leaders Say Agitation to Intensify

10 April 2021
The farmers kept the Manesar-Palwal Highway adjacent to Delhi closed for 24 hours on Saturday.

Pagination

  • Next page ››

More

  • Lingaram Uikey (back row centre) who claims to be a police informer was made to surrender under the Lon Varratu scheme along with five others on February 19 this year. The five others included Pandey Kawasi ( on the right of Lingaram) who allegedly died by suicide in police custody four days after the surrender.

    Surrender of Alleged Informers, Villagers as Maoists Raise Suspicions on Chhattisgarh Govt’s Lon Varratu Scheme

  • Farmers Block KMP Highway as Warning to Intensify Struggle

    Farm Laws: Farmers Block KMP Highway as Warning to Intensify Struggle in Coming Days

  • COVID-19 Spreading In Telugu States at Alarming Rate

    COVID-19 Spreading In Telugu States at Alarming Rate

  • Tamil Nadu: Increasing COVID-19 Cases, Govt Struggling on Education Front

    Tamil Nadu: Increasing COVID-19 Cases, Govt Struggling on Education Front

  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with
about