NewsClick

NewsClick
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Covid-19
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • International
  • Sports
  • Articles
  • Videos
search
menu

INTERACTIVE ELECTION MAPS

image/svg+xml
  • All Articles
  • Newsclick Articles
  • All Videos
  • Newsclick Videos
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • Sports
  • International
  • Africa
  • Latin America
  • Palestine
  • Nepal
  • Pakistan
  • Sri Lanka
  • US
  • West Asia
About us
Subscribe
Follow us Facebook - Newsclick Twitter - Newsclick RSS - Newsclick
close menu
×
For latest updates on nCOVID-19 around the world visit our INTERACTIVE COVID MAP
Conflict
Politics
India

An Unequal Society’s Struggle to Change

Solipsism is the malady and empathy a cure.
Ajay Gudavarthy
30 Sep 2019
Mahatma Gandhi

Trinidadian-British writer VS Naipaul may have got his historical thrust wrong, but may have been on point with other articulations about India. India remains, as the titles of two of his ‘India Trilogy’ books say, A Wounded Civilization and an Area of Darkness.

India’s is a complex society. Its overlapping features do not lend themselves to easy social analysis. German political philosopher Freidrech Hegel had represented India as a “stagnant Orient” due to its caste system. What India is witnessing today with the rise of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and its parent, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), is this insidious civilisational aspect. Caste—not just as a sociological variable but as a deeply psychological criterion—is key to understand why this combine and its abrasive politics is on the rise.

The ladder-like structure of the caste system has created segmented and mutually hostile social groups. Each rung perceives the society and politics around it from its own vantage point. Social location thus determines how individuals view what they see. Over time, this system has produced a wounded psyche: Almost all social groups are caught up in the same process of psychological injury and historical bereavement.

In such situations, there occurs a pervasive sense of loss of the self, either in history or by history. While those placed on the lower rungs of the caste echelon lose their sense of self in history, the elite castes have lost it due to historical changes that have come about. Therefore, self-confidence is still an unresolved issue in India. This is not only true for the “lower” castes, but even for the upper echelons. The result is that India’s social elites do not really represent a self-confident identity.

Such a pervasive sense of being wounded and betrayed and of loss of self, when it cuts across castes, fuels a widespread negation of being. This universal sense of loss is what the Right has been able to mobilise. They understand this deep “civilisational” lack over which most modern processes are built and worked into reality. In India, reality is far too injurious, and too difficult to come to terms with.

While the elite-castes feel a sense of betrayal, the non-elite castes feel a sense of humiliation. It is this process that the Right understands all too well, and it they take it beyond the binary divisions of modern-constitutional sensibilities. Change—or social transformation—is neither linear nor gradual nor cumulative. It is painful, transitive and tendentious.

In such a social formation, dreams, imagination and fantasy are always inextricably mixed with reality and quotidian everyday life. We live because we fantasise about both our past and our future. As Jean Jacques Merleau-Ponty, the French existentialist said, our dreams are nothing but a particular mode of human existence in general.

Fantasy and the imaginary are not unreal but “an oblique approach to presence and being”. In a society that suffers from a perennial diffidence, inferiority and uncertainty about social status and recognition that cuts across caste, religion and region, fantasy and imagination play a significant role in re-constituting a sense of self and a semblance of confidence.

Right-wing politics emerges from this deep reality. It, in fact, belongs to this reality and does not merely make use of it. It represents the epitome of such civilisational wounds. It understands that social groups continue to suffer from a pervasive sense of loss of self. There is no easy way to move from here towards self-reflexive subjectivity or transparent dialogue.

What the Right is doing is to wedge open and stoke this suffering. It is allowing it to express itself in its most crude and unreflexive form. It is promising redemption in being retributive. It is promising liberation from inner repression. It is asking us to find meaning in others’ suffering and dignity in our own suffering. Every social group, from the brahmins to the dalits, are finding this proposition attractive. This is because it provides them with an opportunity to externalise the sense of humiliation that was being silently suffered.

This form of politics is generalising the pervasive sense of injury, thereby exposing society to an underlying existential reality. This is a reality that secular-constitutionalism attempted to bury, without first finding a resolution—a kind of burial before death.

Redemption through retribution has its own path dependency. That is, once triggered, it cannot easily be retrieved. This is why Gandhi always emphasised self-control, brahmacharya and limiting the self. This is why his philosophy prioritised ‘need over greed’ and ‘internalising over externalising’. He even read varna dharma as a mode of self-limiting. Only later in life did he realise the more debilitating psycho-social dimensions.

What the Right is doing is lift the lid off guilt, apprehension and self-doubt. Even as social groups are at loggerheads with each other, even as castes are fighting each other, they are simultaneously are moving into the fold of the Right. This is how the language and articulation that the Right is providing has become the default language of the nation.

The latest in the repertoire is to link this deep sense of loss and wounded self with sexual fantasy, as in the case of Kashmiri women after the virtual abrogation of Article 370. Psychoanalysis was always deeply invested in libido as fundamental to how humans live, think and act. Gujarat in 2002 witnessed gory sexual violence. Such violence becomes a conduit between the inner struggle to connect to one’s own self and the concrete expression of majoritarian might.

Sexualising majoritarianism can play this psychological role more fundamentally than mob lynching or even genocide. It resonates against “civilisational humiliation” and the deeper revulsion against being regulated, disciplined or asked to find self-control (“in spite of being a majority”).

The veneer of guilt is washed away to feed a new kind of expression. The Slovenian philosopher Slavoj Zizek has argued that the rise of the Islamic State and the “sex slaves” they employ has to do with deeply regulated European societies that have got excessively governmentalised. In India, it has to do with historical wounds, primarily arising from being a caste-based society. Sexualising is by far the most concrete and urgent expression of militant majoritarianism having arrived.

Ajay Gudavarthy is Associate Professor, Centre for Political Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi. Views are personal.

Get the latest reports & analysis with people's perspective on Protests, movements & deep analytical videos, discussions of the current affairs in your Telegram app. Subscribe to NewsClick's Telegram channel & get Real-Time updates on stories, as they get published on our website.
Kashmir
Article 370
Psychoanalysis
violence
inequality
Caste
humiliation
History and transformation
Related Stories
‘Guided Tour’: Foreign Envoys from 24 Countries Visit Kashmir

‘Guided Tour’: Foreign Envoys from 24 Countries Visit Kashmir

Kashmir journalist

I Thought There Was No Dowry Related Problem in Kashmir, Says Women’s Commission Chief

Julio Ribeiro

Julio Ribeiro: People of Punjab Wouldn’t Want Khalistan Problem Again

RTI

Life after Article 370: A Little Hope Flickers for RTI Act, 2005

Kashmir 4g

J&K: Internet Normalcy Returns After 1.5 Years, 4G Services Active

Rs 30,757 Crore Grant in Union Budget Fails to Impress J&K

Rs 30,757 Crore Grant in Union Budget Fails to Impress J&K

health

Budgeting for Universalization of Indian Public Health Care Sector: Lessons from Covid-19?

Parliamentary Standing Committee to Jammu & Kashmir

Parliamentary Committee Skips Jammu During Visit to Assess Tourism Industry, Draws Flak

ambedkar and constitution

Political Scientist Neera Chandhoke on the Preamble, its Promises and their Betrayal

Militant Activities Increasing in J&K Border Districts with Higher Recovery of Arms, Say Security Officials

Militant Activities Increasing in J&K Border Districts with Higher Recovery of Arms, Say Security Officials

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share

Related Stories

Anees Zargar

More Room for Politics Expected in J&K as Restrictions Eased on Hurriyat Leader Mirwaiz Umar

04 March 2021
Srinagar: The authorities in the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir have finally ended the restrictions on Mirwaiz Umar Farooq, who was detained
Sagrika Kissu

J&K: Property Tax Imposition Comes under Criticism from Political Parties

25 February 2021
The Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) administration led by Lieutenant Governor (LG) Manoj Sinha issued a notification last week imposing pro
Raja Muzaffar Bhat

Life After Art. 370: How J&K Government Insults Covid Warriors

19 February 2021
Kashmir’s sanitation workers, who include local Muslims and Valmiki labourers, are being paid Rs. 100 or Rs.

Pagination

  • Next page ››

More

  • TMC, AIADMK Release Candidate List for Assembly Polls

    TMC, AIADMK Release Candidate List for Assembly Polls

  • HP eco down

    Himachal Pradesh to Clock Negative Growth of 6.2% in FY21 Due to Pandemic: Eco Survey

  • Coronavirus-Hit  Maharashtra  Economy to Contract 8% in FY21: Eco Survey

    Coronavirus-Hit Maharashtra Economy to Contract 8% in FY21: Eco Survey

  • chian gdp

    China Sets Over 6% GDP Target in 2021 as Economy in Rebound Mode

  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with
about