NewsClick

NewsClick
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Covid-19
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • International
  • Sports
  • Articles
  • Videos
search
menu

INTERACTIVE ELECTION MAPS

image/svg+xml
  • All Articles
  • Newsclick Articles
  • All Videos
  • Newsclick Videos
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • Sports
  • International
  • Africa
  • Latin America
  • Palestine
  • Nepal
  • Pakistan
  • Sri Lanka
  • US
  • West Asia
About us
Subscribe
Follow us Facebook - Newsclick Twitter - Newsclick RSS - Newsclick
close menu
×
For latest updates on nCOVID-19 around the world visit our INTERACTIVE COVID MAP
Health
Politics
India
Economy

Modi Govt’s Bizarre Unconcern with Hunger and Poverty

Even when India is 16th from the bottom in the Global Hunger Index, the NITI Aayog’s claim that policy change is in ‘right direction’, is based on questionable comparability.
Prabhat Patnaik
28 Oct 2019
Global Hunger Index

Representational image. | Image Courtesy: The Print

The news that India’s rank in 2019, according to the Global Hunger Index (GHI), was 102nd among the 117 countries for whom this index was calculated (it is not calculated for countries where hunger is not a problem), instead of causing consternation as it should have, has generated a rather inconsequential debate. This debate ironically has been concerned with two issues.

One is whether India’s rank, which was 55 in 2014, has fallen dramatically to 102 in 2019. And the second, where the NITI Aayog has been an active participant, whether the direction of change in India with regard to the components that go into the GHI has been right.

On the first issue, it has been argued that, since countries with a GHI score less than 5 (even after leaving aside the rich countries which are not covered anyway) have sometimes been included within the list of countries and sometimes shown separately, no conclusions can be drawn about a slippage in India’s precise ranking.

In fact India’s rank was 55 out of 76 countries in 2014, which slipped to 80 (out of 104 countries) in 2015, 97 (out of 118) in 2016, 100 (out of 119) in 2017, 103 (out of 119) in 2018 and 102 (out of 117) in 2019. And the GHI reports themselves say that “Rankings and index scores from this table cannot be accurately compared to rankings and index scores from previous reports.”

As for the NITI Aayog’s argument that no matter what the rank the country occupies, the direction of change has been right, i.e, that the individual components which make up the hunger index, have, each of them, been showing an improvement over time, this is just a sleight of hand.

The GHI incorporates four different components: under-nourishment (inadequate calorie intake for the population as a whole), child “wasting” (the proportion of children under 5 who are “wasted”, i.e have lower weights for their heights), child stunting (the proportion of children under 5 who have low weights  for their age), and child mortality (the mortality rate among children less than 5).

The NITI Aayog uses the findings of the Comprehensive National Nutrition Survey (CNNS) to argue its case that the direction of movement has been right. But the CNNS is a survey of just one point of time. Hence the NITI Aayog’s conclusion is based on comparing the CNNS with a previous survey undertaken by another organisation; and the comparability between the two is questionable.

Besides, it does not even cover all the different components of the GHI. The first component of the GHI, it may be recalled, concerns the calorie intake for the population as a whole. What has been happening to this calorie intake over time is not revealed by any of the currently available official data sources.

The National Sample Survey used to systematically undertake a large sample survey every five years that obtained information about expenditures by households on various items of consumption and on the basis of that information worked out the calorie intake of these sample households. Between the quinquennial surveys it also used to undertake annual surveys covering a smaller sample of households.

The NSS quinquennial surveys, incidentally, were among the largest sample surveys undertaken anywhere in the world and constituted the main data source for researchers on various aspects of the Indian economy. But the latest year for which such survey data are available until now is 2011-12. Since then no NSS data for calorie intake have appeared; what has happened to the NSS under the Bharatiya Janata Party government remains a mystery.

If the NITI Aayog was really serious about its argument, that in India the direction of movement with regard to hunger was right, then it should have had the courage to restore the NSS to its rightful position as a data source, instead of using all sorts of incomplete information with questionable comparability to make an essentially ideological point.

Now, leaving aside all these debates, there are two unambiguous conclusions which can be drawn from the GHI for 2019. The first is that among all the South Asian countries, India has the lowest rank in terms of the GHI in 2019. And the second is that there has been an alarming rise in the prevalence of child “wasting” (i.e the proportion of children under 5 who are underweight relative to their height, reflecting acute under-nutrition), between 2010 and 2019.

These two unambiguous conclusions have a profound significance. Let alone Sri Lanka and Bangladesh, even Nepal, which is among the poorest countries in the world and is categorised by the United Nations as one of the “Least Developed Countries”, has a GHI score that is higher than India. Likewise, even Pakistan which is currently afflicted by a serious economic crisis, has a higher GHI score than India. Earlier, India had a score higher than Pakistan; but in 2019 that ordering has been reversed.

India, prior to the recent slowdown, has been claiming to be an “emerging economic superpower”; and for a while, when India’s rate of GDP growth even exceeded that of China, making it the fastest growing economy of the world (no matter what the veracity of the GDP estimates and hence of this claim), the BJP government never let the country hear the last of it. And yet this “emerging economic superpower” has a hunger index that is even worse than of poor Nepal.

How can we explain this bizarre unconcern with hunger and poverty of the people?

Capitalism, of course, is immanently a mode of production that generates wealth at one pole and poverty at another (it is no surprise that Cuba has a GHI of less than 5); but the level of callousness of the ruling establishment towards the conditions of the common people goes beyond what capitalism alone dictates.

For instance, during the very period when hunger has been so acute, India has been sitting on vast amounts of foodgrain stocks and even making large foodgrain exports. If these foodgrains could have been used for the people’s consumption, then we could have brought down the extent of hunger in the country quite significantly. Why does this not happen?

The level of callousness by the ruling establishment towards the conditions of the common people not only goes beyond what capitalism per se would dictate, but even exceeds what prevails in other countries. There are, in short, specifically Indian roots of this callousness; and one such root obviously is the caste system. If those belonging to the dalit and other “backward” castes are not even considered “equal” to the upper castes, then this very institutionalised inequality militates against any sympathy being shown towards them; and they largely constitute the poor.

In other words, we have a social structure where the inequality engendered by the capitalist system is superimposed upon the inequality institutionalised by the caste system to generate a brew of callousness that is unparalleled anywhere in the world. This fact has become particularly manifest under the rule of the Hindutva forces; they manipulate the dalits and other backward castes to get their electoral support while being utterly niggardly with respect to any State expenditure for improving their lot.

The recent fiscal measures that the government has announced for stimulating the economy only underscore this point. An obvious measure which would not only have stimulated the economy but also made a dent in poverty and hunger, would have been to enlarge welfare expenditures, whether on education or on healthcare or on MGNREGS. But this government did none of these; it gave away instead Rs 1.45 lakh crore of corporate tax concessions, to no purpose, to India’s super-rich!

Nothing illustrates better the phoney-ness of the BJP’s “hyper-nationalism” than the fact that the very government that prides itself on a high gross domestic product growth does not bat an eyelid when the country occupies the 16th rank from the bottom among all the countries of the world in the matter of hunger. And its top advisory body, the NITI Aayog, is perfectly satisfied claiming (no matter with what little justification) that the direction of movement is right!

Get the latest reports & analysis with people's perspective on Protests, movements & deep analytical videos, discussions of the current affairs in your Telegram app. Subscribe to NewsClick's Telegram channel & get Real-Time updates on stories, as they get published on our website.
Global Hunger Index
India GHI Ranking
NITI Aayog
Hunger in India
Child Wasting India
NSSO
National Sample Survey
Related Stories
NITI Aayog Studying How Judges Can Help Economics Beat Environmental Concerns

NITI Aayog Studying How Judges Can Help Economics Beat Environmental Concerns

Food Scurity

How Economic Survey Masks Real Number of People Excluded from Food Security

Coal mining.

Modi Govt Easing Business in Coal Mining and Thermal Power, Ignoring Ecological Concerns

farm laws.

Farm Laws: India at Cusp of Wholesale Subversion of Constitution

With Exploitative Mills in Wait, TN’s Cane Farmers Apprehensive of New Contract Farming Law

With Exploitative Mills in Wait, TN’s Cane Farmers Apprehensive of New Contract Farming Law

Beedi factory near Nileshwaram, Kerala

The Alarming Drop in the Female Labour Force Participation in India

Bihar Election

Bihar Elections: The Tragic Face of De-Industrialisation

India Ranks 94 in Hunger Index, Behind Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar

India Ranks 94 in Hunger Index, Behind Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar

Veil of Secrecy? RTI on Aarogya Setu Draws a Blank, Only Reveals Rs 4.15Cr Spent on Publicity

Veil of Secrecy? RTI on Aarogya Setu Draws a Blank, Only Reveals Rs 4.15Cr Spent on Publicity

Ventilator Controversy: PMCares or PMCareless?

Ventilator Controversy: PMCares or PMCareless?

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share

Related Stories

Arghya Bhaskar

NITI Aayog: Tunnel Vision and Apathy Hamper Progress?

03 April 2021
In the last week of January, the NITI Aayog released vision documents with proposals for the
Shinzani Jain

Are We Staring at Another Phase of Dilution of PDS in India?

18 March 2021
On February 28, 2020, it was
Sarada Mahesh

Mobile Apps and Aadhaar Seeding Cannot Solve Every Problem India Has

16 February 2021
Whenever a problem arises, the government turns to technology or mobile app rather than solve the underlying problem.

Pagination

  • Next page ››

More

  • Lingaram Uikey (back row centre) who claims to be a police informer was made to surrender under the Lon Varratu scheme along with five others on February 19 this year. The five others included Pandey Kawasi ( on the right of Lingaram) who allegedly died by suicide in police custody four days after the surrender.

    Surrender of Alleged Informers, Villagers as Maoists Raise Suspicions on Chhattisgarh Govt’s Lon Varratu Scheme

  • Farmers Block KMP Highway as Warning to Intensify Struggle

    Farm Laws: Farmers Block KMP Highway as Warning to Intensify Struggle in Coming Days

  • COVID-19 Spreading In Telugu States at Alarming Rate

    COVID-19 Spreading In Telugu States at Alarming Rate

  • Tamil Nadu: Increasing COVID-19 Cases, Govt Struggling on Education Front

    Tamil Nadu: Increasing COVID-19 Cases, Govt Struggling on Education Front

  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with
about