NewsClick

NewsClick
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Covid-19
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • International
  • Sports
  • Articles
  • Videos
search
menu

INTERACTIVE ELECTION MAPS

image/svg+xml
  • All Articles
  • Newsclick Articles
  • All Videos
  • Newsclick Videos
  • हिन्दी
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Science
  • Culture
  • India
  • Sports
  • International
  • Africa
  • Latin America
  • Palestine
  • Nepal
  • Pakistan
  • Sri Lanka
  • US
  • West Asia
About us
Subscribe
Follow us Facebook - Newsclick Twitter - Newsclick RSS - Newsclick
close menu
×
For latest updates on nCOVID-19 around the world visit our INTERACTIVE COVID MAP
sports
India
International

Hima Das’ Gold Medals and the Need for a Realistic Perspective

For a nation starved of sporting success outside of cricket, any success is glorious. But, it is time to change that culture and understand the context of victories and the standards involved. Hima Das’ gold medal wins — while worthy of polite applause — need to appreciated with perspective.
Leslie Xavier
22 Jul 2019
Indian athlete Hima Das

Hima Das won five gold medals in various athletics meets in Poland and the Czech Republic in July, but a closer analysis shows that her performances and the field in those meets have been below par.

Anything without a perspective and a reference point is meaningless. That’s why in athletics there are records — world and Olympic marks — which provide a yardstick, an existing quantifiable mark for greatness so that when we herald new champions we do it ensuring justice to not just the young athlete, but the greats of yore and the sport as a whole. The way India has celebrated Hima Das’ success over the past fortnight — her five gold medals in 15 days to be exact — lacks all of this: perspective, insight, and respect to athletics. 

In fact, it demeans our country and presents Indians in poor light — as a bunch of people with poor sporting standards who go around celebrating whatever comes our way. 

Being a cricket crazy nation, maybe we don’t understand performance benchmarks in other sports. Let’s start by painting Hima’s performance in cricketing colours. The 19-year-old’s five gold medal wins would be equivalent to winning a five-match ODI series against Afghanistan, or against one of those associate nations who never gets to play the ICC World Cup. Nothing more.

Also Read | International Cricket Establishment’s Anti Expansion Drive, An Inside Story

This, by no means, is an attempt to take away what Hima has achieved in the past. Her tale, overcoming adversity, to reach where she is now, is remarkable. So is her victory out of the blue at the IAAF Junior World Championships last year. 

But that performance, or her personal bests, or her gold medals in the five events this month, are not good enough to gain her a berth at the IAAF World Championships scheduled to be held in Doha in September-October this year. The qualifying route for the Worlds is a two-pronged system, one being ranking points from IAAF sanctioned events, and two being through attaining the qualifying mark (timing in track events and distance in throws and jumps).

Only a handful of athletes have made it to the Worlds from India. Marathoner T Gopi, Avinash Sable in steeplechase, Neeraj Chopra in javelin (courtesy of being ranked in the top 10 in world rankings), Ayyasamy Dharun in 400m hurdles have managed tickets for Doha, while the rest, including Hima, Dutee Chand and many other celebrated athletes, have a little over 60 days to try and qualify. 

The attempt is on and that’s why our athletes are in Europe, taking part in competitions to improve their performances. Then again, taking part in obscure meets where Indians, despite poor personal bests, lead the start list as top seeds, defies any sporting logic. By any stretch of convention, across any sport, to improve, one needs competition that is better. Taking part in events against average athletes, who are even below you in the global pecking order, serves no purpose here. It does not even serve the short-term goal of qualifying for the World Championships.

Also Read | Dutee Chand Reveals She's in Love with Another Woman; Here's Why it Matters

If the Athletics Federation of India (AFI) and the Sports Authority of India (SAI), which decides the events and manages tours of the athletes, is figuring out ways for our athletes to win events and gain ranking points, then, competing in meets where more points are offered should be the priority. 

Take for instance the five events Hima and the other Indian athletes took part and won in July — Poznan Athletics Grand Prix and Kutno Athletics meet in Poland; Kladno Memorial, Tabor athletics meet and Velká cena Nového Města nad Metují (Nove Mesto) in the Czech Republic. Out of the five events only three are listed by the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) as eligible for ranking points, the ones in the Czech Republic. And, these events are graded as Category ‘E’ by the IAAF in the ranking system. 

Besides the Worlds, Olympics and continental events, the IAAF ranking system has six grades for competitions (A to F). The ‘F’ category events are the lowest in the pecking order and comprises of national-level competitions. Hima, in essence, won gold medals in events which were international, no doubt, but only slightly above our nationals in grading. 

That’s just one half of the story. In Nove Mesto, where Hima won her fifth gold medal, the 400m women’s start list had seven Indian athletes in the top 10, with Hima being the topper. That presents a real and not-so-rosy picture. If it’s a national level competition that we are seeking, then why spend so much money on travelling across Eastern Europe when our athletes could have competed against each other at home? The national athletics body, and not the athletes, should answer and try and justify this.

One can’t find any justification or logic to be clear.

These instances clearly demonstrate why Neeraj Chopra, India’s only world class athlete at the moment, and his coach Uwe Hohn, prefers charting the events themselves, which has, in the past, put them at loggerheads with the country’s sports babus.

Also Read | Jithin Paul vs NADA: Doping and the Indian Athlete

As far as Hima’s personal performances are concerned, her career best in 200m is 23.10 seconds. Her best gold-winning time in the distance (season’s best) is 23.25. The World Championships qualifying mark for 200m is 23.02 and the championship record is 21.63. The World & Olympic Record is 21.34 while the winning time at the Rio Olympics in 2016 was 21.78.

The disparity is equally glaring in the 400 event. She managed a season’s best time of 52.09 seconds in Nove Mesto, which is slower than her personal best of 50.79 (Asian Games last year). The World Championships qualifying mark is 51.80 and the world mark is 47.64. A time of 49.44 earned Shaunae Miller gold in the event at the Rio Olympics.

On a personal front, Hima’s gold would definitely be a confidence boost for the young athlete. Then again, an athlete’s psyche would get a better boost when he or she knows that the glitter around the neck comes with the backing of a solid performance on the track or field and not by default because the competition was substandard.

Hima, at 19, is hitting a critical juncture in her career. She was the junior world champion last year and should make that big leap from age-group to senior benchmarks round about now. That leap can only be made through systematic exposure and moulding. The fact that she was sidelined by injuries through the best part of offseason, and has only started competing and trying to improve mid-season, is proof of the gross mismanagement of our athletes by the sport’s governing mechanism. 

Showering them with accolades and applause will do little other than provide an ego boost. Any world class athlete will corroborate this. A short-term wound to the ego is a long term gain for their performance. The path is clear. What would we rather chart for? Accolades, applause and congratulations for substandard meets on Twitter? Or meaningful records, medals and a legacy that will stand for longer than the press of a refresh key?

Read more sports stories from Newsclick

Get the latest reports & analysis with people's perspective on Protests, movements & deep analytical videos, discussions of the current affairs in your Telegram app. Subscribe to NewsClick's Telegram channel & get Real-Time updates on stories, as they get published on our website.
Hima Das
Hima Das gold
Hima Das records
Hima Das five gold medals
Hima Das athletics
Hima Das athlete
Indian athletics
IAAF World Championships
Hima Das village
Neeraj Chopra
IAAF World Athletics Championships Doha
Doha 2019
Tokyo Olympics
Rio Olympics
Dutee Chand
Ayyasamy Dharun
T Gopi
Athletics Federation of India
Sports Authority of India
IAAF World qualifying marks
Athletics world records
Related Stories
olympics

Tokyo Olympics Organising Committee Plans Cost Cutting Measures, Will Ask Foreign Athletes For Training Plans Before Games

ciriello

Hockey India Exodus Continues With Chris Ciriello Resignation

FIFA World Cup qualifiers new dates

FIFA President Infantino Concerned Over Delayed World Cup qualifiers; Zinedine Zidane Praises 'Spectacular' Bale Impact and More (Football Round-Up)

National Sports Awards 2020: Arjuna award, Dronacharya, Khel Ratna

National Sports Awards 2020: Increase in Numbers at the Expense of Legacy?

The 2020 Arjuna Awards and Khel Ratna Awards

The More the Murkier: Increasing Quota of Arjuna and Khel Ratna Awards Demeans Their Significance

Indian hockey team defender Surender Kumar

Hockey India Crises: Surender Kumar Hospitalised Again, High-Performance Director Resigns

Tokyo 2020 in 2021, the wait continues for the opening ceremony of Olympics and the festival which follows

Tokyo 2020: The Wait Begins Now, For a Better Games

India's greatest Olympic Underdog stories

The Big Games Debate Part 2: India's Greatest Underdog Stories (Tokyo 2020, The Olympic Fortnight Series)

Greatest of all time Indian Olympian

The Big Games Debate Part 1: India's G.O.A.T. (Tokyo 2020, The Olympic Fortnight Series)

V Devarajan, Indian boxer with former world champion Enrique Carrion

Integrity via Harmony: The Cuban Boxing Philosophy That Shaped India

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare via EmailShare on RedditShare on KindlePrint
Share

Related Stories

Newsclick Sports

IOC President Thomas Bach Optimistic About Fans Attending Tokyo Olympics

16 November 2020
Having met the Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga, International Olympic Committee (IOC) president Thomas B
Newsclick Sports

World Champion Christian Coleman Banned for Two Years, Set to Miss Tokyo Games

28 October 2020
The Athletics Integrity Unit (AIU) confirmed on Tuesday that the world 100 meters champion Christian Coleman ha
Newsclick Sports

Four Nation Gymnastics Event To Be Hosted By Tokyo In November

13 October 2020
The Japan Gymnastics Association (JGA) have announced that Tokyo will host an international gymnastics competition on November 8.

Pagination

  • Next page ››

More

  • XI jinping.

    Pandemic Far from Over, but Winter Can’t Stop Spring: Xi Jinping

  • Telangana: Turmeric Farmers Demand BJP MP Arvind’s Resignation

    Telangana: Turmeric Farmers Demand BJP MP Arvind’s Resignation

  • COVID-19: Latest Sero Survey Hints Delhi Could be Heading Toward ‘Herd Immunity'

    COVID-19: Latest Sero Survey Hints Delhi Could be Heading Toward ‘Herd Immunity'

  • farmers march 26th jan.

    Farm Laws: Lakhs of Farmers to Hold Tractor Rally on Republic Day

  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with
about